Need tile roof repair in Winter Park? Clay barrel tile and concrete tile are part of what makes Winter Park look like Winter Park, from the Spanish style buildings of Rollins College to the Mediterranean Revival homes near Lake Maitland and the concrete tile on newer lake homes and rebuilds. Tile lasts a long time, but it is not armor. Tiles crack under falling oak limbs and careless feet, ridge mortar loosens, and the layer that actually keeps water out, the underlayment under the tile, wears out long before the tile does. Home Pros Roofing and Contracting is a licensed Florida roofing contractor based in Apopka that has repaired and replaced roofs across Orange County and Central Florida since 2015, and our phone is answered 24/7.
This page is for Winter Park homeowners with a tile roof and a problem: a ceiling stain, a broken tile on the lawn, a crooked ridge after a storm or an insurance letter about roof age. It covers how Florida’s rules say tile must be installed, what a proper repair looks like, when repair stops making sense, and the city, historic, HOA and insurance details that apply here. Every rule we quote is tied to a source at the end of the page. To talk about your roof now, call 407-766-4388.
Tile roof repair in Winter Park at a glance
- Who we are: Home Pros Roofing and Contracting, a licensed roofing contractor based in Apopka, serving Winter Park, Maitland, Orlando and Central Florida since 2015.
- Florida licenses: Certified General Contractor CGC1527172 and Certified Roofing Contractor CCC1332789.
- Tile we work on: clay barrel tile, clay and concrete S tile, flat concrete tile, and their hip, ridge, rake and valley details.
- Typical repairs: cracked and slipped tiles, loose ridge and hip tiles, failed mortar or foam, leaks at walls, chimneys, parapets and pipes, and worn underlayment.
- Paperwork: we fill out Citizens and insurance roof inspection forms, and we pull the permit when the job needs one.
- Availability: 24/7, including after storms.
Why so many Winter Park homes have tile roofs
Winter Park was incorporated in 1887 and became a city in 1925, in the middle of the Florida land boom. The Winter Park Register of Historic Places, which the city keeps, is full of homes built in 1925, 1926 and 1927, and many houses of that era were built in the Spanish and Mediterranean Revival styles: stucco walls, arches, courtyards and red clay barrel tile on the sloped sections, often with a flat roof hidden behind a parapet.
Rollins College set the tone. Its archives credit Miami architect Richard Kiehnel with carrying the Spanish Mediterranean style across the campus, from Rollins Hall in 1929 to the Annie Russell Theatre in 1932. Knowles Memorial Chapel, designed by Ralph Adams Cram and dedicated in 1932, follows Spanish forms of the 17th century, and the college’s own history says the roofs of the chapel and the theatre are covered in Spanish barrel tile, a look that has stayed consistent across the campus for almost a century.
The most famous tile roof in town may be Casa Feliz, the Andalusian farmhouse that architect James Gamble Rogers II designed for Robert Barbour in 1932. The Winter Park Library archives describe its clay barrel roof tiles as handmade, and the Orange Observer reported that Rogers used reclaimed Cuban tile from the old Orlando Armory. Facing demolition in 2000, the house was saved by the community and moved about 300 yards across Interlachen Avenue in 2001 to its spot beside the Winter Park Golf Course. It is listed on the Winter Park Register of Historic Places.
Tile did not stop with the 1930s. The large lot Mediterranean homes in the Vias, the streets off Interlachen Avenue near Lake Maitland, still read as a barrel tile neighborhood, and the city register includes a 1926 home on Via Tuscany. Newer custom homes and rebuilds on lake lots often carry concrete tile in barrel, S or flat profiles. So a tile repair here might mean an old clay roof on a designated landmark or a concrete tile roof finished a few years ago, and the right repair is different for each.
Clay barrel tile or concrete tile: know what is on your roof
The two look alike from the street and behave differently on a ladder. The Florida Building Code, Residential, requires clay roof tile to comply with ASTM C1167 and concrete roof tile to comply with ASTM C1492, and sends both to the same installation rules.
- Clay tile is fired clay. On many older Winter Park homes it is a two piece barrel system, with pan tiles in rows and cover tiles over the joints, or a one piece S tile with the same look. Old clay tile can be brittle, and some profiles and colors are no longer made, so salvaged tile from a hidden section is often the only true match.
- Concrete tile is molded from cement and sand in barrel, S and flat shapes, with color mixed through or applied as a surface coat that weathers. Replacement tile from the same maker is often available, but new tile next to 20 year old tile rarely matches at first, so we move older tiles to visible faces and put new ones where they will not be seen.
- Mixed roofs are common: clay tile on the main roof, a membrane flat roof behind the parapet and a later addition in concrete tile or shingles, each with its own repair method and flashing.
The underlayment is the real waterproof layer
The tile is not what keeps your ceiling dry. The FRSA and Tile Roofing Industry Alliance manual that Florida’s code relies on, the Florida High Wind Concrete and Clay Tile Installation Manual, Seventh Edition, describes a properly installed tile roof as a water shedding assembly. Tile throws off most of the rain and shields what is beneath it from sun and wind, but some water always gets under tile in a Florida downpour. The underlayment on the deck stops it.
That is why a tile roof can leak when every tile looks perfect from the street. Underlayment dries out and cracks, laps open and the flashings tied into it corrode. Section R905.3.3 of the code says underlayment under clay and concrete tile must follow the underlayment maker’s instructions in line with the FRSA and TRI manual. The current manual allows a single ply, self adhered underlayment of at least 40 mil applied to the deck, or a compatible two ply system, and warns that mixing parts of different systems can shorten the life of the roof.
That leaves three kinds of tile work:
- A spot repair: replace broken or slipped tiles, reset ridge or hip tiles or rework a flashing while the underlayment beneath is still sound.
- A tile lift and relay: the tile is good but the underlayment is not. We take the tile off the affected slopes, protect it, replace the underlayment and flashings and set the same tile back, adding salvaged or matching tile for any that break.
- A full replacement: when tile and underlayment are both worn out, or the code requires the whole roof or section to be redone. Our page on roof replacement in Winter Park covers that project.
We tell you plainly which one your roof needs, with photos from the roof, and put the scope and price in writing before any work starts.
Tile roof problems we see under Winter Park’s oaks
- Cracked and broken tiles. Oak limbs fall on roofs during summer storms and hurricanes, and one heavy branch can crack a row of tiles. Foot traffic does it more quietly: dish installers, pressure washers and light hangers who step on the middle of a tile leave hairline cracks behind.
- Slipped and missing tiles. Tiles set with too little adhesive, or with corroded fasteners, slide down and open a gap. A missing tile exposes the underlayment to direct sun, which breaks it down fastest.
- Loose ridge and hip tiles. Ridges sit where the wind pulls hardest. Old mortar beds crack and let go, and a ridge tile that falls in a storm can break the field tile below.
- Valleys full of leaves. Oak leaves and acorns pack valleys and gutters, water backs up and runs sideways under the tile to the edge of the valley metal.
- Wall, chimney and parapet flashing. Where tile meets stucco, a chimney or the parapet around a flat roof, cracked stucco and old counterflashing are a common leak source on Mediterranean Revival homes.
- Pipes and vents. Lead skirts and flexible flashings wear out, get chewed by squirrels or were never woven into the tile coursing.
How a tile repair should be done
A tile roof punishes shortcuts. These are the rules we follow, taken from the FRSA and TRI manual and the code that adopts it:
- Walk the roof the right way, or not at all. The manual tells installers to caution everyone against traffic of any kind on a finished tile roof, because it can damage the tile and the sub roof. We step only where tiles overlap and never send a crew across the middle of clay barrel tile.
- Replace a broken tile without tearing the underlayment. The manual’s method: break out the damaged tile while avoiding disturbing the underlayment, repair the underlayment if it is damaged, trim the lugs on the replacement tile if needed, apply adhesive as its maker directs and set the tile right away so it makes full contact.
- Match the attachment system. Florida tile is held with nails or screws, mortar or polyurethane foam adhesive. The manual notes that foam applied systems require Florida Building Code Product Approval, and it lists which hip and ridge attachment methods go with which weather blocking. We match what is there or redo the whole detail.
- Treat hips and ridges as structural. The code says hip and ridge tiles must be installed under the FRSA and TRI manual, with mortar, foam or a mechanical ridge support, not a fresh bead of mortar over a loose old one.
- Flash it once, correctly. At walls, chimneys and parapets we replace flashing and counterflashing as a system and seal the stucco joint above it.
- Leave the roof clean. A loose shard left in a valley is tomorrow’s dam.
Every replacement tile, underlayment and foam adhesive we install has to carry Florida Product Approval, which anyone can check in the state’s Product Approval system.
Repair or replace: the 25 percent rule and tile roofs
Under section 706.1.1 of the Florida Building Code, Existing Building, not more than 25 percent of a roof or roof section may be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12 month period unless the entire roof or section is brought up to current code. The exception: if the existing roof was built, repaired or replaced under the 2007 Florida Building Code or a later edition, only the part being repaired has to meet the current code.
A concrete tile roof on a newer home or recent rebuild is usually covered by the exception, so a big storm repair can stay a repair. A clay roof on a 1920s or 1930s house last redone before the 2007 code is different: if a third of one slope needs new underlayment, the rule may push the job to that whole section. We check the permit history for your address first, so the scope you sign is the scope the inspector will accept.
Section R905.3.3 also has a tile exception for reroofing: where an existing self adhered underlayment is confirmed on the deck, and any required sheathing renailing can be verified, an approved two ply underlayment can go over it across the entire roof. Only a small test opening shows whether that applies to your roof.
Permits for tile roof repair in Winter Park
Inside city limits, roof permits come from the City of Winter Park Building and Permitting Services department through its Self Service Portal. The city’s permit guide lists reroofing among the jobs that need a permit and lists only minor roofing repairs of one square or less as exempt. A roofing square is 100 square feet, so replacing a few cracked tiles is very different from relaying a slope, and starting work without a required permit can cost triple the permit fee.
- Contractor registration. A state licensed contractor must be registered with the city, with license, liability coverage and workers compensation proof on file.
- Inspections. Larger tile work goes through the city’s dry in inspection, with the underlayment on and before tile goes back, and the final.
- Emergency work. When a leak has to be stopped right away, the permit application is due the next working business day.
- Historic properties. The permit checklist asks for Historic Preservation Board approval, when it applies, for reroofs and other exterior changes.
- Code edition. The Florida Building Code, 9th Edition (2026) takes effect on December 31, 2026, and the permit application date decides which edition applies.
A Winter Park mailing address does not always mean a city permit. Some homes with Winter Park addresses sit in unincorporated Orange County, where permits go through the county’s Fast Track system, and a few sit on the Seminole County side. We look up the parcel first.
Historic homes: tile, the Winter Park Register and Certificate of Review
The City of Winter Park Historic Preservation Division keeps the Winter Park Register of Historic Places and oversees changes to designated properties. Local districts include the College Quarter Historic District west of Rollins College and the Virginia Heights East Historic District, and listed homes are spread across the city. The Downtown Winter Park Historic District and the Interlachen Avenue Historic District are separately listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
A designated landmark or a home in a local district needs a Certificate of Review for exterior alterations. The application says the Historic Preservation Board generally follows the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation, that applications are due at least 24 days before the board meeting and that the board acts within 60 days. On a tile roof:
- Like for like repairs with matching tile in the same profile, color and ridge detail are the easiest to justify. Ask the Historic Preservation Division how your repair will be treated before work starts.
- Material changes, such as clay barrel tile to concrete, shingles or metal, get a close look, because the tile is often a character defining feature of the house.
- Matching old tile is a real constraint. When a historic profile is no longer made, we salvage tile from hidden slopes, porches or outbuildings for the visible faces.
HOA approval in communities like Windsong
Some Winter Park tile roofs answer to a homeowners association instead. Windsong, which its community association calls the last new neighborhood of Winter Park, sits on Lake Virginia and Lake Berry and runs through an association, as do other newer enclaves. HOA documents often control tile color and profile, so a repair that changes either may need approval first.
Under section 720.3035(6) of the Florida Statutes, every HOA board or architectural committee must adopt hurricane protection specifications and may not deny an application that conforms to them, and the statute’s definition of hurricane protection includes roof systems recognized by the Florida Building Code that meet ASCE 7 22 standards. The board can still require you to follow an existing unified building scheme, so a matching tile in an approved color is usually the smoothest path.
Lakes, oak canopy and storms in Winter Park
The city’s lakes run from Lake Sue, the uppermost lake in the Winter Park Chain of Lakes, whose outflow passes through Mead Botanical Garden into Lake Virginia, down to Lake Maitland, the lowest. Many homes on and near the chain sit under mature oaks, which means leaves in the valleys all year and heavy limbs over the roof in every storm.
During Hurricane Ian, the city reported 72 tree incidents in its parks and rights of way and 2,560 customers without power on September 29, 2022. Hurricane Milton in October 2024 was gentler here; the city said it fared well, with 275 customers out at the peak, though the National Weather Service in Melbourne recorded gusts of 55 to 75 mph across Orange County, locally as high as 87 mph. Gusts like that test ridge and hip attachment first, and one falling limb can break a row of clay tile.
The Atlantic hurricane season runs June 1 through November 30. The quiet months are the time to reset loose ridges, replace cracked tiles and clear valleys.
Insurance, roof age and Citizens forms for tile roofs
Under section 627.7011(5) of the Florida Statutes, an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowners policy solely because of the age of a roof that is less than 15 years old. For a roof 15 years or older, the insurer must allow an inspection by an authorized inspector before requiring replacement, and may not refuse coverage on roof age alone if that inspection shows 5 years or more of useful life remaining.
Citizens Property Insurance treats tile as a hard roof. Its inspection page says roofs older than 25 years for soft coverings, or 50 years for hard coverings such as tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal, need documentation of at least five years of remaining useful life, and Citizens uses its own Roof Inspection Form, RCF-1. As a licensed roofing contractor, we fill out Citizens and insurance roof inspection forms, with photos. See our guides to the Citizens roof inspection form and the 4 point roof inspection, or our non renewal roof guide for Central Florida.
Insurers may also ask for an updated wind mitigation report once tile work is finished. Home Pros Roofing and Contracting arranges wind mitigation inspections through partner companies; our page on wind mitigation inspections in Orlando explains the form. Owners of older homes may also want to read about the My Safe Florida Home roof grant.
After a storm: what to do with a damaged tile roof
- Stay off the tile. Wet tile is slick and broken tile is sharp. Look from the ground and from the attic.
- Take photos of broken tile, ridge lines, ceiling stains and fallen limbs before anything is moved.
- Stop the water. We can tarp or dry in the damaged area while the repair is planned. Call 407-766-4388, 24/7.
- Keep the pieces. Broken tile helps us identify the profile and color.
- Report it promptly. Florida law sets time limits on property insurance claims.
See also storm damage roof repair, emergency roof repair and roof leak repair.
Winter Park neighborhoods where we repair tile roofs
- Olde Winter Park and Park Avenue: historic streets around Central Park and the Charles Hosmer Morse Museum of American Art, with 1920s homes under old oaks.
- The Vias: large lot Mediterranean and Spanish Revival homes off Interlachen Avenue near Lake Maitland.
- College Quarter and Virginia Heights: local historic districts near Rollins College and Lake Virginia.
- Windsong: newer homes on Lake Virginia and Lake Berry, many with concrete tile and HOA rules.
- Lake Sue and Mead Garden: lakefront and canopy streets near the top of the chain.
- Aloma Avenue and the east side: midcentury homes and rebuilds near the city’s Winter Park Pines Golf Club, where parcels may fall under the city or Orange County.
For general roofing in the city, see our roofer in Winter Park page; just north, our Maitland roofing page; and across the metro, tile roof repair in Orlando. You can also read about tile roofs, roof repair for other roof types or our Orlando roofing contractor page. Home Pros Roofing and Contracting is based in Apopka.
Why Winter Park homeowners call Home Pros for tile repair
- Licensed. Florida Certified General Contractor CGC1527172 and Certified Roofing Contractor CCC1332789, searchable on the DBPR license lookup.
- Certified. TAMKO Pro Certified Contractor and CertainTeed ShingleMaster, for the shingle sections that often sit next to tile.
- Local since 2015. Based in Apopka, serving Winter Park and Central Florida, with the phone answered 24/7.
- Straight answers. Roof photos, a plain explanation of repair, relay or replacement, and the price in writing before work starts.
- Financing. Financing is available for good, fair and bad credit through Service Finance and Foundation Finance; see roof financing for good, fair and bad credit.
Home Pros Roofing and Contracting is a member of The Good Contractors List, an exclusive network that approves contractors only after a rigorous vetting process. Very few Florida contractors meet that standard, which is why you will find so few of them listed. Qualifying work is backed by the list's $25,000 third party workmanship guarantee, so you can hire with confidence. View our Good Contractors List profile.
Have a cracked tile, a crooked ridge or a stain on the ceiling? Call 407-766-4388, email [email protected] or send us a message. We will look at the roof, show you what we find and give you a written estimate.
Home Pros Roofing and Contracting, 1935 Rafton Rd, Apopka, FL 32703. Phone 407-766-4388. Email [email protected].
Tile Roof Repair in Winter Park: FAQs
How do I know if my Winter Park tile roof needs repair or replacement?
It depends on the tile and the underlayment beneath it. A few cracked tiles or a loose ridge over sound underlayment is a spot repair. Good tile over worn underlayment can usually be lifted and relaid on new underlayment. Replacement makes sense when both layers are worn out or the code requires the whole section to be redone. We show you roof photos and explain which case you are in.
Can you match the clay barrel tile on my older Winter Park home?
Often, but not always with new tile, because some 1920s and 1930s clay profiles and colors are no longer made. We take sound tile from a hidden slope, porch or outbuilding for the faces people see and use the closest available match where it will not show. Keep broken pieces after a storm; they help identify the tile.
Why is my tile roof leaking when none of the tiles look broken?
Because tile is not the waterproof layer. The FRSA and TRI manual describes a tile roof as a water shedding assembly, and the underlayment on the deck stops the water. Worn underlayment, open laps, corroded wall or chimney flashing, a failed pipe flashing or a valley packed with oak leaves can all leak under tiles that look perfect.
Do I need a City of Winter Park permit to repair a tile roof?
For anything beyond a small repair, yes. The city's permit guide lists only minor roofing repairs of one square, 100 square feet, or less as exempt, and unpermitted work can cost triple the permit fee. Homes outside city limits get the permit from Orange County or Seminole County instead, so we check the parcel first.
My home is on the Winter Park Register of Historic Places. Can I repair the tile roof?
Yes. Designated landmarks and homes in local districts such as College Quarter and Virginia Heights East need a Certificate of Review for exterior alterations. Matching repairs in the same profile and color are the simplest case, while changing clay tile to another material gets a close look. Ask the Historic Preservation Division first, and allow for the 24 day filing window and the 60 day decision window if review is needed.
Does the 25 percent rule apply to tile roofs in Winter Park?
Yes. Section 706.1.1 of the Florida Building Code, Existing Building, limits repairs to 25 percent of a roof or roof section in any 12 month period unless that section is brought up to current code. Roofs built or replaced under the 2007 Florida Building Code or later are exempt, which covers many concrete tile roofs on newer homes but often not older clay roofs.
Will my insurance company accept an older tile roof?
Under section 627.7011(5), an insurer cannot refuse a policy solely because a roof under 15 years old is too old, and for older roofs it must accept an inspection showing at least 5 years of useful life. Citizens asks for that documentation on tile and other hard roofs older than 50 years. Home Pros fills out Citizens and insurance roof inspection forms with photos.
Does my HOA have to approve a tile roof repair?
Check your documents. Many HOAs, including newer Winter Park communities, control tile color and profile. Under section 720.3035(6), an HOA must adopt hurricane protection specifications, which can include qualifying roof systems, and may not deny a conforming application, but it can still require you to follow the community's unified building scheme.
Is it safe to walk on my tile roof to check it?
We do not recommend it. Wet tile is slick, old clay tile is brittle and stepping on the middle of a tile can crack it. The FRSA and TRI manual warns against traffic of any kind on a finished tile roof. Look from the ground and the attic and leave the roof to a licensed roofer.
What should I do if a storm breaks tiles on my Winter Park roof?
Stay off the roof, photograph the damage, keep the broken pieces and report the damage to your insurer promptly. If water is coming in, call 407-766-4388; Home Pros is available 24/7 and can tarp or dry in the area while the repair is planned.
Do you offer financing for tile roof repair or a tile lift and relay?
Yes. Financing is available for good, fair and bad credit through Service Finance and Foundation Finance. You get the written scope and price first, so you know exactly what you are financing.
Sources
- FRSA and Tile Roofing Industry Alliance, Florida High Wind Concrete and Clay Tile Installation Manual, Seventh Edition (PDF)
- Tile Roofing Industry Alliance, installation guides (Seventh Edition effective December 31, 2023)
- Florida Building Code, Residential 2023, Chapter 9, section R905.3 clay and concrete tile
- Florida Building Code, Existing Building 2023, Chapter 7, section 706.1.1
- Florida Building Commission, Product Approval system
- City of Winter Park, Building and Permitting Services
- City of Winter Park, Do I Need a Permit? (PDF)
- City of Winter Park, Residential Construction Permitting Plan Guide (PDF)
- City of Winter Park, Historic Preservation and the Winter Park Register of Historic Places
- City of Winter Park, Certificate of Review Application (PDF)
- City of Winter Park, Lakes General Information
- City of Winter Park, Hurricane Ian Update 5, September 29, 2022 (PDF)
- City of Winter Park, Hurricane Milton Update 5, October 10, 2024 (PDF)
- City of Winter Park, Winter Park Pines Golf Club
- National Weather Service Melbourne, Hurricane Milton county impacts (PDF)
- National Hurricane Center, tropical cyclone climatology
- Orange County, Roof Permit
- Wikipedia, Fairview Shores, Florida (unincorporated Orange County)
- Wikipedia, Goldenrod, Florida (Orange and Seminole counties)
- Florida Statutes, section 627.7011
- Florida Statutes, section 627.70132 (notice of property insurance claims)
- Florida Statutes, section 720.3035
- Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections
- Florida DBPR, Construction Industry Licensing Board
- Wikipedia, Winter Park, Florida
- Wikipedia, Downtown Winter Park Historic District
- Wikipedia, Interlachen Avenue Historic District
- Rollins College Archives, main campus architects
- Rollins College Archives, Knowles Memorial Chapel
- Rollins College, Rollins and Winter Park, exemplars of the American Renaissance
- Casa Feliz, our history
- Winter Park Library Archives, Casa Feliz
- Orange Observer, Casa Florida: the romance of Spanish design
- Karen O'Neil, The Vias and Olde Winter Park neighborhood comparison
- Windsong Community Association
- Charles Hosmer Morse Museum of American Art (Wikipedia)
